Cover Crops for Weed Management
It’s the time of year when Ontario farmers are turning their attention to seeding cover crops following cereal harvest. Each grower has their own reasons for growing a cover crop – whether it’s to improve organic matter, hold onto nutrients from manure, provide a nitrogen credit or protect against erosion. In this report, we will explore how cover crops can help manage weeds. We will discuss which species are most effective, share a couple of Ontario examples and provide tips on how to avoid cover crops becoming weeds themselves.
How cover crops suppress weeds
Cover crops can suppress weeds in three main ways: through competition for resources (e.g. water and nutrients), modification of the soil environment (e.g. mulch preventing light penetration) and direct interaction with weeds via allelopathy. The degree of weed suppression depends on how quickly the cover crop establishes, how competitively it grows and whether it releases allelopathic compounds. Lasting surface residue is also beneficial. Cover crops are much more effective suppressing annual weeds versus perennials, which have well-established root systems and energy reserves.
A cover crop such as radish, which establishes and canopies very quickly, is an excellent weed fighter in the summer and fall. However, it leaves very little surface residue in spring, causing minimal residual weed suppression. Species such as winter rye or triticale don’t generate much biomass in fall but can grow aggressively and canopy fully if seeded early. In spring, they green up quickly and compete with early emerging annual weeds. These species also release allelopathic chemicals and can provide surface residue following termination.
For growers looking for a simple approach, straight oats (Figure 1) or a mixture of oats and radish can be very effective in suppressing weeds during the late summer and early fall. Those who are comfortable with overwintering species will benefit from added suppression of early-season annuals. The decision depends on your cropping system and your other goals for the cover crop.
Ontario research: impacts on glyphosate-resistant Canada fleabane
Recent research from the University of Guelph, Ridgetown Campus, led by Taïga Cholette, evaluated seventeen different cover crop single and multi-species combinations for their effects on glyphosate-resistant (GR) Canada fleabane suppression in corn. Cover crop treatments that included oilseed radish provided the fastest ground cover. All treatments provided greater than 75% suppression of Canada fleabane in May compared to a no cover crop control. However, the greatest and longest-lasting suppression was seen in treatments that included overwintering species such as cereal rye and annual ryegrass.
None of the cover crops evaluated provided full control of GR Canada fleabane and certainly should not replace primary forms of weed control. Also, relatively high seeding rates were used; at rates more typical to Ontario farms, expected weed suppression would be less. Nonetheless, this research highlights the value cover crops can bring in managing herbicide-resistant weeds.
On-farm case study
This season provided a strong example of the weed-suppressing power of cover crops to a Haldimand County grower. He drilled cereal rye last fall (40 lbs/acre) into his entire field except for a small section separated by a ditch. This spring, he planted IP soybeans into the rye before spraying it off. The field received a tank-mix of Roundup®, Canopy™ Pro and Boundary®.
By early July, the field was very clean (Figure 2A). The small section on the other side of the ditch, however, had a high density of fleabane plants poking above the soybean canopy (Figure 2B). Similar examples have been provided in recent years by Ontario growers who grow rye either as a crop or cover crop.
Cover crop cautions
While cover crops can provide weed management benefits, they can also pose risks. Certain species can be challenging to control in the spring and can themselves become weeds. Annual ryegrass, despite its weed suppression abilities, is very difficult to terminate and has escaped control in numerous instances in Ontario. Also, some species can unexpectedly overwinter and may not be controlled by a glyphosate-only burndown, depending on their growth stage. Figure 3 shows such an example, where purple-top turnip survived winter, was not killed in mid-May with a high rate of glyphosate and produced viable seed. Early control is key to achieving effective termination in such cases.
The bottom line
Cover crops are a tool that can augment the weed management program on your farm. If you’re new to cover crops, start small and simply with species that winterkill. If you are looking for additional weed suppression, consider species like cereal rye that provide spring growth. Integrating cover crops requires planning and additional management but can provide strong benefits, especially in assisting to control herbicide-resistant weeds.
- Making Cover Crops Pay – Managing Weeds webinar, featuring Dr. Francois Tardif (University of Guelph), Mike Cowbrough (OMAFRA) and farmers Charlene Whattam and Mark Burnham. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cEigJV8DMJs)
- The Midwest Cover Crops Council Cover Crop Decision Tool provides detailed information on cover crop management, including individual “Weed Fighter” ratings for different species. (https://mccc.msu.edu/covercroptool/)
Cholette TB, Soltani N, Hooker DC, Robinson DE, Sikkema PH (2018) Suppression of Glyphosate-resistant Canada Fleabane (Conyza canadensis) in Corn with Cover Crops Seeded after Wheat Harvest the Previous Year. Weed Technology. 32:244–250. doi: 10.1017/wet.2018.19
|Location||Weekly July 26 – August 1||Accumulated|
|Year||Highest Temp (°C)||Lowest Temp (°C)||Rain (mm)||Rain (mm) April 1st||GDD 0C April 1st||GDD 5C April 1st||CHU May 1st|
|Report compiled by OMAFRA using Environment Canada data. Data quality is verified but accuracy is not guaranteed. Report supplied for general information purposes only. An expanded report is available at www.fieldcropnews.com.|